Impulse 87: Board Notes

Mark Laskow

CARNEGIE’S OWN ‘SOCIAL EXPERIMENT’ DRAWS ON QUALITIES FROM THE HEART

Although Robert Owen shared a Scottish heritage with Andrew Carnegie, Owen was more likely to have employed Carnegie’s father in one of his textile mills than to have worked alongside him. Owen developed a reputation in Scotland for treating his workers particularly well. He decided to launch a utopian community in the United States based on community ownership of property and equality of incomes. He lavished resources on his project to give it the best possible start. He bought a town, Harmonie, Indiana, with 20,000 acres, 160 existing buildings, working mills, and farms already producing food. To bring this dream to life, Owen recruited a group of inhabitants that included scientists, teachers, and geologists.

Owen’s ultimate objective was to create a “New Moral World, a world of enlightenment and prosperity leading to human happiness defined as mental, physical, and moral health enjoyed in a rational way of life … to replace the Old Immoral World of ignorance, superstition, selfishness, and suffering,” according to Dr. Donald E. Pitzer, a University of Southern Indiana historian, whose 1989 Ohio Journal of Science article chronicled the transport of prominent scholars to the American Frontier in the 1820s.

Nevertheless, Owen’s experiment failed. Despite endless wrangling among the residents and constant innovation and inventive tinkering by Owen, a good portion of the residents did not work but subsisted on the work of others. Many productive members of the community found this intolerable. By early 1827 New Harmony had failed and was abandoned.

What has that to do with our Carnegie Heroes?  Well, they, too, are a minority within their communities who perform difficult and dangerous work for the benefit of others. We recognize them as heroes and present them with medals precisely because they do for others what almost no one else is willing or able to do. Unlike the residents of New Harmony, Indiana (its modern name), that does not dissuade Carnegie Heroes from their efforts. And while the residents of New Harmony gave up after fewer than three years, the Carnegie Hero Fund has been chronicling the rescues of its heroes for 122 years now and, of course, the heroes were at work long before the Hero Fund was formed and there is every indication heroism will continue.

You might argue that New Harmony was an economic failure that had nothing to do with heroism. But economics is just a special subset of the broader study of human behavior. Andrew Carnegie and his Hero Fund with an even narrower segment of human behavior.

What is different? Could it be that New Harmony dealt with economic greed and the Carnegie Hero Fund deals with more idealistic concerns? It appears from history that along with Owen the early settlers of New Harmony were sincere idealists who wanted the whole idea to work, but for some of them, so long as it did not involve doing actual work themselves. The laggards of the New Harmony community, who brought about its failure, may have joined the community with idealistic political views, but that was not enough to get them out into the fields to work for the food which they themselves would eat.

The Carnegie Heroes, on the other hand, pay a terrible price at times. They risk death to attempt a rescue which will not benefit themselves in any way. These people are clearly driven by something more powerful than intellectual ideas or social beliefs. They seem driven by something they find in their human soul, which moves them to do this.

It is interesting to contrast the motivations of Robert Owen and Andrew Carnegie. Owen’s motivation was clearly intellectual; it looked to the “head.”

According to historian Dr. Penelope Harris, “Owen firmly believed that ignorance was the cause of crime and social unrest, and could be resolved through education, leading to a better and happier way of living.” Harris, a retired Fellow of the Institute of Administrative Management, has studied 1800s America, including the lives of architect Jospeh Hansom and Robert Owen extensively.

When Andrew Carnegie created the Hero Fund, he seemed to be reaching for something within the human heart, something beyond rational calculation. He crafted the Carnegie Hero criteria to exclude any kind of financial incentive to make a rescue.

Most recipients never knew the Carnegie Medal existed before they attempted their rescue. Even among those that were aware of the medal, there is no evidence that receiving it ever factored as motivation. The motivation to do what they do came, perhaps less from their brains than from their hearts and souls.  Aren’t we all the wonderful beneficiaries of that!

(In case you are interested in the New Harmony experiment, I have included a link to the online essay that motivated me to write this article: New Harmony, Indiana – Wikipedia and QotD: The history of New Harmony, Indiana « Quotulatiousness. I am indebted to the author of the essay but be clear that I applaud neither the creation of the New Harmony community nor its failure.)